How to Sell

The Buying Counter is taking a short break as of November 22! Follow us at @banditmke on Instagram for updates!


Buying Counter Operations
  • No appointment necessary. Wait times may vary. Please be kind.
  • You must be 18 years old to sell to Bandit MKE. If you are under 18, please bring a parent, guardian or friend. You must present a photo ID to check-in your items, and we are required to capture and store an image of your ID.
  • An associate will process your buy and may or may not select items. A non-negotiable cash offer will be presented to you. You are welcome to accept or decline the offer.
  • Buying offers are paid out at 15-20% of the retail price. Please do not ask for more money than you are offered
  • Payouts under $100 will be made in cash. Payouts created than $100 will be made via PayPal or check.
  • Items left 24 hours beyond your pickup window will be considered abandoned. Bandit MKE is not responsible for items abandoned at our shop.
  • The Buying Counter may close at any time without notice if we have reached capacity. When the Buying Counter closes all walk-in buys will be declined. 
  • Please call ahead at (414) 459-1254 if you have a large amount of items.

**We reserve the right to refuse any items at any time for any reason**


  • Anything with rips, stains, tears, holes or other forms of damage or excessive wear
  • Items we have declined to buy from you previously
  • Items that do not belong to you
  • Items with odors - please launder or dry clean your garments before you arrive
  • Wedding or bridal attire
  • Sportcoats or suit jackets
  • Housewares, textiles/linens, or decorative items
  • Out of season items
  • Modern items from low-cost mainstream retailers like Forever 21, H&M, Target, Kohls, etc.